Retrospective Tools

Mural vs ScatterSpoke

A side-by-side look at scores, pricing, features and integrations to help you pick the right retrospective tool.

Mural logo

Mural

6.6

Visual collaboration whiteboard with a mature facilitation toolkit and AI-assisted sessions

Mural is a long-established visual collaboration platform — an infinite canvas with sticky notes, anonymous voting, timers, Private Mode, 250+ workshop templates (eight of them retro-specific), Mural AI (cluster, summarise, mind-map, Classify by emotional tone), and a Facilitation Superpowers toolkit (Outline, Timer, Voting, Private Mode, Summon, Celebrate) refined for over a decade. Best-in-class enterprise posture: SSO/SAML with multi-IdP support, SCIM, SOC 2 Type 2, ISO 27001, GDPR and NA/EU/APAC data residency.

Full review →
ScatterSpoke logo

ScatterSpoke

5.7

AI copilot for team feedback

ScatterSpoke was rebuilt from scratch as v3 in August 2026: retro boards, static and agent-run surveys, a Signals engine that detects morale, burnout and psychological-safety patterns in feedback text, and an Ask layer that answers questions with cited evidence. An official OAuth MCP server is included on every tier, including Free.

Full review →

Summary

Mural scores 6.6 overall and is best for workshop-heavy teams (design, product, agile coaching) that want a polished facilitation canvas with strong retro templates and enterprise-grade controls. It offers a free tier.

ScatterSpoke scores 5.7 overall and is best for engineering orgs that want AI to synthesise feedback across many teams and surveys — and agent builders who need a survey backend over MCP. It offers a free tier.

Mural leads on value, fun factor, integrations, open platform and enterprise-grade. ScatterSpoke leads on ease of use, retro toolkit and AI & insights.

Across our eight scoring dimensions, Mural edges ahead with an overall score of 6.6. That said, the right pick depends on your team — see the dimension-by-dimension breakdown below.

Scores compared

Mural
Ease of Use7.0
Retro Toolkit5.0
Value5.0
Fun Factor6.5
AI & Insights5.5
Integrations7.5
Open Platform7.0
Enterprise-grade9.0
ScatterSpoke
Ease of Use8.0
Retro Toolkit6.5
Value3.0
Fun Factor3.0
AI & Insights9.0
Integrations4.0
Open Platform6.0
Enterprise-grade6.0
DetailMuralScatterSpoke
CategoryWhiteboardRetrospectives
Team sizeMid-marketMid-market
Free tierYesYes
Free limitUnlimited murals but only the 3 most recently created stay editable (older go view-only); unlimited members and visitors; no Mural AI1 seat; unlimited static surveys and responses; 10 Agent Surveys and 50 Ask queries one-time; 5 of 15 signal rules; MCP connection but no reading results over it
Starting price$9.99/user/mo$29/user/mo
Est. 3 teams × 8 people$240/mo billed annually$814/mo on Business (includes 5 seats; 19 extra seats at $35/seat/mo) — Pro is capped at 5 seats
EnterpriseYesYes
Founded20112019
HQSan Francisco, USUSA
Data residencyUnited States · European Union · Asia-Pacific—
Languages9 (English, Spanish, German, …)English only
Export formatsImage · PDF · PowerPoint · HTML · CSVCSV · PDF
Features4046
Integrations83

Feature & integration comparison

Side-by-side checklist across features, integrations and security. Hover a note for details.

CapabilityMuralScatterSpoke
Features
Custom templates✓✓note
Anonymous input✓note✓
Health Checks—✓note
Action tracking✓note✓note
Async mode✓✓
Whiteboard✓—
Independent voting✓✓
Polling✓note✓note
Icebreaker games——
Agile Estimations✓note—
Team Kudos——
AI grouping/clustering✓✓note
AI action items—✓note
AI Summaries✓✓
Team Insights—✓
In-meeting AI assistant✓✓
Action dashboard——
Integrations
Asana✓note—
Azure DevOps✓note—
Basecamp——
ClickUp——
Confluence✓—
GitHub✓note—
GitLab——
Jira✓note✓note
Linear——
Microsoft Teams✓✓
Monday.com——
Notion✓note—
Shortcut——
Slack✓✓
Trello——
Security & Privacy
SOC 2✓✓note
GDPR✓✓
SSO / SAML✓note✓note
SCIM provisioning✓note✓note
ISO 27001✓—
On-premises——
Public API✓✓note
Webhooks——
MCP server✓note✓

Mural — pros

  • + Mature facilitation toolkit — Outline, Timer, Voting, Private Mode, Summon, Celebrate — refined over 10+ years
  • + Anonymous where it counts: votes hide who voted, and Private Mode can keep sticky authors hidden even after reveal
  • + Best-in-class enterprise posture: SOC 2 Type 2, ISO 27001, GDPR, SSO/SAML (multi-IdP), SCIM, NA/EU/APAC residency
  • + Jira and Azure DevOps work-item cards now carry configurable and custom fields and can be edited inside the mural
  • + Five export formats (PDF, PNG, PPT, HTML bundle, CSV of stickies) — unusually broad for a canvas tool

Mural — cons

  • − Per-seat pricing: a 24-person org pays ~$240/mo on the Team+ tier (annual), well above retro-native tools at that headcount
  • − No native health checks, mood tracking or longitudinal team-pulse
  • − No recurring retros, action carryover or cross-team rollup — facilitators rebuild structure each sprint
  • − AI (clustering, summary, tone Classify) helps inside a session but doesn't track trends across retros
  • − SSO/SAML needs the $17.99/user/mo Business tier; SCIM, audit logs and data residency are Enterprise-only
  • − Public API has no webhooks, and the MCP server is still early-access beta

ScatterSpoke — pros

  • + Official MCP server on every tier including Free — OAuth, no API keys to mint; reading results is where the paid line sits
  • + Signals engine with fifteen built-in rules and a detect-then-critique pass before anything is recorded
  • + Ask names the survey or retro behind every answer, and cross-retro theme trends ship on paid plans
  • + Unusually precise public docs — a per-tier entitlement table that names exactly what each plan gates
  • + Guest join by verified email or open link, and guests never consume a seat

ScatterSpoke — cons

  • − $814/mo for 3 teams of 8 on Business (5 seats included, then $35/seat); Free is a single seat
  • − <strong>Action items are no longer part of the v3 retro flow</strong> — the Review phase records outcomes as card comments
  • − Manual grouping was removed; clustering is AI-only and board columns are fixed at creation
  • − The v3 integration entitlement covers only Slack, Teams and email — no Jira, GitHub or Azure DevOps setup is documented
  • − One CSV export from a closed retro; audit logs, data retention and org-wide AI are Enterprise-only

Keep comparing

Not sure which to pick? Read our guide on how to choose a retrospective tool.